Bitcoin miners found a way to profit without mining BTC, but the advantage may not last
Surging Texas electricity prices made shutting down more profitable than mining Bitcoin for some operators in early November.
The disruption contributed to Bitcoin's 9.13% mining difficulty reduction on Nov. 14, its largest since June, as expensive electricity forced miners to reconsider whether keeping their machines running was worthwhile.
In a Nov. 17 analysis, mining services firm Luxor found that West Texas electricity prices exceeded the mining revenue of a machine operating at 25 joules per terahash during 45% of the hours between Oct. 29 and Nov. 14. That compares with just 9% during the preceding difficulty period.
The pressure intensified between Nov. 7 and Nov. 11, when average daily electricity prices ranged from $64 to $122 per megawatt-hour. Meanwhile, the modeled mining equipment generated approximately $54 in revenue for every megawatt-hour consumed, before electricity and other operating costs.
Luxor estimated that higher electricity prices alone accounted for roughly four-fifths of the increase in unprofitable mining hours, suggesting energy costs drove the disruption rather than Bitcoin's declining price.
The resulting shutdowns reduced the computing power securing Bitcoin's network, contributing to the difficulty adjustment that lowered the measure to 134.82 trillion from 148.36 trillion.
Why switching off can pay more than mining Bitcoin
While miners exposed to wholesale electricity prices could avoid losses by shutting down, companies with favorable power contracts had another opportunity.
Bitcoin mining company Riot Platforms, for example, can temporarily suspend operations and return contracted electricity to the grid in exchange for credits when market prices exceed its fixed electricity rates.
According to its third-quarter SEC filing, Riot earned $24.7 million in power curtailment credits during the three months ended Sept. 30, including $22.9 million from voluntarily reducing electricity consumption.
Those earnings preceded November's electricity surge but demonstrate how the arrangement works.
Consider a miner generating $54 in Bitcoin revenue per megawatt-hour while paying a fixed electricity rate of $35.
Continuing operations would produce $19 after electricity costs. However, if wholesale electricity prices reached $100 and the operator could return its contracted power, it could receive a $65 credit instead.
Under those assumptions, switching off would generate $46 more per megawatt-hour than continuing to mine.
What switching off pays
The same power price can make a wholesale miner stop to avoid a loss and give a miner with resale rights a reason to collect a credit.
Payoff per megawatt-hour under two electricity contracts A wholesale buyer loses 46 dollars when mining. A miner on fixed power earns 19 dollars by mining or gets a 65-dollar credit by returning the same power. ILLUSTRATIVE INPUTS PER MWh$54Mining revenue$100Market power$35Fixed-rate powerNET PAYOFF PER MWh$0Buy at wholesale and mine−$46Mine on fixed-rate power+$19Return fixed-rate power+$65$46 more by switching off
Payoff per megawatt-hour under two electricity contracts A wholesale buyer loses 46 dollars when mining. A miner on fixed power earns 19 dollars by mining or gets a 65-dollar credit by returning the same power. ILLUSTRATIVE INPUTS PER MWh$54Mining revenue$100Market power$35Fixed-rate powerNET PAYOFF PER MWh$0Buy at wholesale and mine−$46Mine on fixed-rate power+$19Return fixed-rate power+$65$46 more by switching off
With a fixed electricity price and resale rights, giving up $19 in mining margin can earn a $65 credit in this example.
Illustrative operating economics before other costs. $100/MWh and $35/MWh are scenario assumptions. Real credits depend on the contract and applicable market price. This does not estimate Riot's rates or actions in November.
Sources and evidence
Sources
- Luxor's modeled mining revenue
- Riot's disclosed power-credit terms
Supporting facts
- In an illustrative $100/MWh market hour with gross mining revenue of $54/MWh, a miner buying at wholesale would lose $46 on power for each MWh it consumed. With an illustrative $35/MWh fixed contract and the right to return electricity at the market price, a miner would earn $19/MWh over contracted power cost by mining or receive a $65/MWh manual credit by idling, a $46/MWh advantage to curtailing. [1] [2]
- Riot said it can power down and return contracted electricity to the utility, receiving a credit for the difference between the applicable market price and its fixed power price. It reported $22.938 million in manual curtailment credits and $1.726 million in demand response credits, totaling $24.664 million, in the three months ended Sept. 30. [2]
Method
Per MWh, subtract $100 from $54 for wholesale mining, $35 from $54 for fixed-rate mining and $35 from $100 for the return credit. The credit is $46 above the fixed-rate mining margin. All bars share a zero and use the same dollars-per-MWh scale within each view.
Scope
Illustrative operating economics before other costs. $100/MWh and $35/MWh are scenario assumptions. Real credits depend on the contract and applicable market price. This does not estimate Riot's rates or actions in November.
Infographic by CryptoSlate
That difference helps explain why electricity markets can influence Bitcoin mining activity independently of cryptocurrency prices.
Bitcoin's 9% difficulty relief faces a rapid reversal
However, the relief from November's shutdowns may prove short-lived.
Luxor estimated that Bitcoin's computing power recovered to approximately 1,100 exahashes per second as West Texas electricity prices eased between Nov. 13 and Nov. 15, even as Bitcoin's price continued falling.
The recovery accelerated block production after the difficulty reduction, raising the prospect of another substantial adjustment.
Through Nov. 17, Bitcoin blocks had averaged approximately 9.11 minutes since the reset, faster than the network's targeted 10-minute interval.
If that pace persists throughout the current difficulty period, the next adjustment could increase difficulty by approximately 9.85%, reversing nearly all the previous reduction. Even if block production slows to 10 minutes for the remaining period, the early acceleration would still produce an estimated 2.72% increase.
The extent of that rebound will depend partly on whether Texas electricity prices remain low enough to keep miners operating.
-- Price
This content is provided for general informational purposes only and doesn't constitute financial, investment, legal, or tax advice. Any events, rewards, online promotions, or related information mentioned herein should not be considered a recommendation, solicitation, or invitation to purchase, sell, trade, or otherwise deal in any crypto assets. Crypto assets are highly volatile and may result in loss. The availability of WEEX services, products, and related events may vary by region. You are responsible for ensuring that your participation is in accordance with applicable local laws and regulations.
You may also like

Should You Buy Amazon Stock Before the Holiday Season?

Nvidia's Board of Directors Is Not Planning to Reinstate Jensen Huang. But There's Still Another Way He Could Return as CEO

4 Financial Stocks to Buy That Gained in 2022's Bear Market While the S&P 500 Lost 19%

Relaxed but Ruined: The Law That Sells Your Seized Bitcoins Before Your Trial Arrives at the Senate on Thursday

Bitcoin options flash warning as downside premiums surge ahead of Fed minutes

Anthropic’s Claude completes a 16-hour human research job in under 3 hours

Is Micron Next to Announce a Stock Split?

Elon Musk Deepfake Confronts 500,000 People: Coinbase's AI Agent Blocks 99% of Scam Attempts

Hims & Hers Launches New Peptide Therapy, Acknowledging Efficacy Still Needs Further Research

IonQ Stock Plunged 48% in Six Months. Is It a Bargain Buy?

Hackers from Binance Target Ethereum! Moving Hundreds of Thousands of ETH

Bill Gurley: Free AI is Google's 'top' strategy against Anthropic

Tencent: WorkBuddy Achieves Annualized Revenue of Over $500 Million in Seven Days, More Than Twice That of Tencent Meeting

History Says AGNC's Dividend Can Survive a Stock Market Crash -- but Not Always at Full Size

With Democrats to Control Congress, Is It Better to Buy Bitcoin or an Index Fund?

Solana Foundation Acquires Majority Stake in CoinGecko, A Crypto Traffic Battle Unfolds Behind 18 Million Users

I've Been Wrong About Paypal Stock for 2 Years. Here's Why I'm Finally Changing My Mind.

AI Will Make the Next 12 Months 'a Slaughterhouse' for Crypto Security: Anchorage Exec

IBC Protocol: Proof Matters, Not the Messenger

Wells Fargo Raises Disney Target Price to $140, Positive Outlook for Theme Park Business

Prediction: $200 a Month Invested in SpaceX Could Be Worth This Much by 2035

Is the Stock Market Really in an AI Bubble? Wall Street's Doomsayers Are Ignoring Crucial Facts.

AI Agent Faces Obstacles: Controllable Permissions More Urgent than Payments

Warnings Behind 50 Authorizations: How TBC Tightens Signature Permissions

Texas Approves SpaceX Supercomputer Power Plant Permit After Abbott Lifts Approval Freeze

a16z Frontier Explores AI Agent Sector, Uncovering a New Startup Opportunity

Tesla Is Now Taking Cybercab Orders. Here's Where I Think the Stock Will Be in 2030.

Brothers Exploit Ethereum Vulnerability, Acquiring $25 Million and Found Not Guilty

Tencent Q3 Earnings Preview: Profit May End 16-Quarter Growth, AI Spending and Cash Flow Become Revaluation Focus







